Banana Split

Hannah Marks

April

Liana Liberato

Clara

Dylan Sprouse

Nick

Luke Spencer Roberts

Ben

Meagan Kimberly Smith

Molly

Haley Ramm

Sally

Jessica Hecht

Susan

Addison Riecke

Agnes

Jacob Batalon

Jacob the Manager

Carter Gill

Movie Patron

Travis Przybylski

Cute Dumb Guy

Ben Konigsberg

Mordecai